College Admissions Interviews: What They Are and Why They Matter

When students think about college admissions, their minds often jump to essays, scores, grades, and recommendation letters. But there’s one often-overlooked opportunity that can make a lasting impression—the college admissions interview.

Even though fewer colleges offer them today, interviews remain a powerful way for students to connect with a school on a personal level. They’re not just about answering questions; they’re about creating a conversation, building confidence, and showing genuine interest. They are, in fact, a great tool for demonstrating interest in a particular college. 

Some colleges offer in-person interviews on campus or with alumni, while others conduct them virtually through video calls or online platforms, making them accessible no matter where you live.

Here’s everything your student needs to know about college interviews—why they matter, how to prepare, and what to expect.

1. Timing Is Everything: Check Your Email and Schedule Early

If a college offers interviews, you’ll typically receive an email invitation a few days or weeks after submitting your application. This email will go directly to you, not your parents, so make sure you’re checking your inbox (and spam folder) frequently.

When you get the invitation, act quickly. Interview slots fill up fast, especially at selective colleges or during busy admission cycles. Some schools started opening up summer interviews for rising seniors.

ICC Tip: Create a dedicated folder for college emails and check it daily during application season. Staying organized can make the difference between landing an interview or missing out entirely.

2. What College Interviews Are (and Aren’t)

There’s a lot of confusion surrounding college interviews, so let’s clear up a few common myths:

• MYTH: “If I’m not offered an interview, my chances are ruined.”
• TRUTH: Not all applicants are invited to interview. Availability often depends on geography, staffing, or policy—not your qualifications.
• MYTH: “The interview will make or break my application.”
• TRUTH: Interviews rarely determine the outcome, but they can strengthen your application, especially when multiple students have similar academic profiles.
• MYTH: “Only Ivy League schools do interviews.”
• TRUTH: Many schools offer them, from small liberal arts colleges to public university honors programs and scholarship committees.
• MYTH: “All interviews count the same.”
• TRUTH: Some, like alumni interviews at schools are informational, meaning they don’t directly affect admission decisions. Others, especially those with admissions officers, are evaluative and may hold more weight.

Regardless, every interview is a chance to make a positive impression. Even if the interview feels informal, we remind students to bring their best selves because alumni interviewers still submit their impressions to the admissions team.

3. Why College Interviews Matter

College interviews aren’t just about impressing the admissions team—they’re about connection.

• For colleges, interviews help personalize the process. They allow admissions officers (or alumni) to see your enthusiasm, curiosity, and fit with their campus culture.
• For students, interviews are a platform to tell your story beyond grades and test scores. They’re also a great way to ask thoughtful questions and learn more about the school.

Even if an interview is optional, taking it shows initiative and genuine interest. It signals that you care enough to go the extra mile, and colleges always notice this.

4. Which Colleges Offer Interviews?

Every school handles interviews differently, but here’s a general overview:

• Highly Selective Universities (e.g., MIT, Stanford, Dartmouth): Often offer alumni interviews when available.
• Liberal Arts Colleges (e.g., Dickinson, Bates, Grinnell): Frequently provide interviews through admissions officers or regional representatives.
• Large Public Universities (e.g., University of Michigan, UNC-Chapel Hill): Typically don’t offer interviews due to applicant volume.
• Art and Design Schools: May require interviews or portfolio reviews as part of the admissions process.

Policies vary, so always double-check each college’s admissions website or contact your ICC counselor if you’re unsure.

5. How to Make the Most of Your College Interview

A successful college interview doesn’t require a perfect script. It requires preparation and authenticity. Here’s how to approach it:

• Do your research: Learn key facts about the college’s programs, values, or traditions so you can ask meaningful questions.
• Practice your story: Be ready to talk about your interests, experiences, and goals but in a conversational way, not rehearsed.
• Be curious: Think of questions that go beyond what’s on the website. Ask about student life, traditions, or opportunities that interest you.
• Show gratitude: Always send a short thank-you email afterward. It’s polite and reinforces your interest in the school.

6. The Hidden Benefit: Confidence Beyond College Admissions

Even if your interview doesn’t directly affect your admission decision, the experience itself is valuable. Practicing how to communicate your strengths, reflect on your experiences, and connect with an adult interviewer will help you later, whether you’re applying for scholarships, internships, or jobs.

Think of your college interview as your first professional conversation. The more comfortable you get now, the more confident you’ll be when it matters most.

A college admissions interview isn’t something to fear; it’s something to embrace. It’s your chance to go beyond grades and essays, to share your story and make a genuine connection.

So check your inbox, schedule early, and show up prepared to be yourself. In a process that can feel impersonal, the interview is one of the few moments that’s all about you.